Turtle Pie Milkshake Recipe - Sizzling Eats (2024)

Shared by Amy Desrosiers | 18 Comments
Updated on May 8, 2023

Thank you Edwards® Desserts for sponsoring this post. Head to the frozen desserts aisle of your grocery store to pick up your favorite Edwards pie!

Turtle Pie Milkshake recipe is a fun & delicious pie milkshake without ice cream. Simply add the pie, and a little milk to a blender, and blend until you have a creamy dessert in a cup. Real whipped cream, chocolate sauce, caramel, and some pecans with chocolate add a tasty finish.

We are officially in the last month of summer. Fall is right around the corner and I can hardly complain. I love the fall season and am just about ready to trade in the hot, humid days for chilly, crisp ones.

But, since summer is almost gone I am also going to enjoy every last drop of the warm sunshine. The best way to do that?

Why we Love Desserts like Edwards Turtle Pie

With a frozen, chilled treat. Sure, ice cream is always an option but I love to live outside of the carton sometimes and explore new treat options.

Why not enjoy a nice frozen slice of Edwards® Turtle Pie, or maybe some Edwards® Hershey’s* Chocolate Crème Pie?

Edwards Desserts are decadent pies that can be found at retailers like Target in the frozen dessert section. They are available in many scrumptious flavors, but we really love the chocolatey goodness of the featured varieties.

These mouth-watering frozen pies from Edwards are so stinking good and can really elevate any function with an easy dessert. They are so tasty and make for an elevated dessert versus just ice cream.

Need a last-minute dessert for a summer BBQ? Maybe your dessert buffet is missing some chocolatey, creamy goodness? That is ok, because Edwards® Turtle Pie, and Edwards® Hershey’s* Chocolate Crème Pie are here to save the day!

They also make the perfect pies for the holidays (hint, hint) and look great alongside some pumpkin and apple pies.

My favorite flavor is the Edwards® Turtle Pie because I love the delicious layers of caramel and tasty chocolate and pecans. It is sooo much better than ice cream anytime of year!

How to Make Whole Pie Milkshakes

Edwards Desserts are perfecto alone, but boy, do they make the perfect shortcut to make whole pie milkshakes. There is no need for ice cream when you blend a pie like Edwards® Turtle Pie.

You can blend ANY Edwards Desserts style pie right from frozen too which makes milkshakes like Key Lime Pie, and Turtle Pie easy, peasy!

How to Make a Turtle Pie Milkshake

Making a pie milkshake without ice cream is super easy! All you need is a small amount of whole milk and 4 slices of Edwards® Turtle Pie. We also used the following ingredients to make our Turtle Milkshake super fun!

This recipe makes 2 large Turtle Milkshakes

• 4 slices of Edwards® Turtle Pie (frozen)
• 1/2 cup whipped cream
• 1/2 cup milk
• 1 tablespoon chocolate chunks
• 1 tablespoon caramel pieces
• 1 tablespoon pecans
• 2 tablespoons caramel sauce
• 2 tablespoons chocolate sauce

Simply add 1/2 the Edwards® Turtle Pie (4 frozen slices) into a blender with half cup of milk. Blend until creamy (about 15 seconds).

Line the two large cups with chocolate and caramel.

Pour the creamy mixture into two large cups.

Top with whipped cream, caramel, chocolate chunks, pecans, and caramel pieces.

Add a straw and enjoy this blissful ice-cold treat that requires NO ice cream to make!