THE 15 BEST Restaurants in Sheridan, WY - With Menus, Reviews, Photos - Updated June 2024 (2024)

Customers` Favorites

“I must say, I was a bit skeptical, I don’t usually leave the house, but I’m REALLY glad we attended the Friendsgiving! Dalton was very kind and informative and patient with us asking questions etc. The atmosphere was laid back and relaxing, the Kava really did just take the edge off, body & mind and just allowed us to joke and enjoy our time there ! Thanks Dalton and Dillyn for the amazing experience! Really cool place you have, we will be back!”

“Veteran owned and operated. Best coffee shop in Sheridan. As a vet this is the most inviting and comfortable coffee shop I’ve been to, if you’re in the area be sure to stop in and enjoy a coffee and a spend a few minutes in back to see all the law enforcement and military patches.”

“We Love The Mint!!!! We just bought squares for the Super Bowl and were wondering why it's one win for the final. Most other Super Bowl polls are each quarter and then the final. This way it gives more people a chance to win. All the employees who work there do an amazing job. You have a great crew.”

Customers` Favorites

“We showed up 10 minutes before closing, and the employees were very kind enough to take our order even after they put everything away for the night. They helped us out with what to order as it was our first time in ever. It was kinda along the lines of a subway sandwich but was higher quality, and the employees actually cared about what they were making. It is attached to a gas station so the atmosphere isn't the greatest but friendly service and a tasty sandwich makes up for it.”

Customers` Favorites

“Cute little coffee shop. Loved the local advertisem*nt board and book. We ordered the Dirty Chai, the French press coffee, a Wild Berry Crossaint, and the Quiche. All of it was great!! The quiche had spinach and sun dried tomatoes and I absolutely loved it! The Wild Berry Crossaint had the best jam I have ever had with a little cream cheese and large sugar cystals on it that topped it off. Definitely a favorite visit of mine ❤️”

“My husband LOVES beer so we like to visit local breweries. While because of state laws etc being in WY they didn't have anything except soda/water for us non beer drinkers, my hubby said the beers were excellent.They allow you to bring in food, so we ordered mexican food from a restaurant just across the street, and they have a very big outdoor game area that our kiddos ran around and played in, and I had a very kind bar tender who really did try to help me find a beer I like. :-) Very cute brewhouse would recommend it to my beer drinking friends.”

Customers` Favorites

“Wow!! The reviews for this restaurant are on point and consistent with my experience. We travel to the Sheridan area and seek out the best restaurants. The restaurant was amazing! Great atmosphere, food, service and beverages!!”

Customers` Favorites

“I can’t think of a better place to get breakfast. Like a glimpse back in time. Impeccable service. Prices decent and food outstanding! What a gem! I will be back!”

Customers` Favorites

“This was our first time dining at Shabby Shack. Its eclectically cute décor is inviting. The GF and regular pizza planks were delicious, the wine pours were very generous, and the staff was attentive. Two suggestions though, the music is too loud, especially if anyone is hard of hearing. Please turn down the music. The second suggestion is to get rid of the little single-use water cups. It seems very wasteful to throw out cups every day instead of washing them. Plus, you could find a nice variety of glasses at a thrift store. The mismatched nature would be a nice addition and improve the overall dining experience.Dietary restrictions: GF options available”

Customers` Favorites

“April 2024Delicious Mexican food.The beans were awesome. Not as good as my wife's, but nobody's is. This is a respectable second.Sept 2023Want Mexican food out of an old school bus experience? This is it! Stopped for a snack. Spicy carnitas taco and carne asada taco. Both were tasty. Well go back.”

Customers` Favorites

“Not a whole lot of options here, just a bunch of very sugary drinks and mini donuts. Everything was great, and the service was friendly. I just wish there were more selection; maybe cold brew and savory breakfasts?”

Customers` Favorites

“The Cowboy Cafe is exactly what you would expect from a small town diner, and that's what makes it good. The prices are all great for the serving size, and the selection of pies really top off any meal. We usually go here a few times a month.”

“What an amazing experience & wonderful hospitality during the Oktoberfest celebration! Thks to Tim, Doug, Jared, Will & the crew for a private tour of the brewery, lots of tasting samples & a super day of fun! This Rapid City crew will definitely make a return trip back!”

Customers` Favorites

“Food trailer. Food was okay. Ordered chili dog and chili fries. Chili needed more seasoning. Canned? I probably won't go back but I know people who love it.”

“One of the better Bars in Sheridan. In the summer it's known as the "biker bar" XD. It's a very nice vibe in the bar. Nothing to really complain about. Only thing that would be a nice touch, is more parking spaces. Other than that, it's a very nice bar.”

“I am an ice cream connoisseur, and this place has by far the creaminess, most flavorful ice cream I've ever had! When we go through Sheridan again, we will for sure be stopping for another scoop, or two or three...”

Customers` Favorites

“I am beyond impressed with the quality of food at midtown. This was the first time I was able to have fried fish tacos gluten free and it was out of this world tasty. Everything about this cafe is just amazing and one of the best chias I have had in a long time. If you have not eaten here or enjoyed their coffee, you are definitely missing out.”

Customers` Favorites

“Great local shop, plenty of seating for working on your tablet or laptop while enjoying a tasty beverage. The food is also delicious and I especially recommend the monster cookie. Great atmosphere, staff is very friendly and this place has a little something for everyone.”

Customers` Favorites

“We had a beautiful Date night at perkins this evening! Huge shout out to Ryanne , she was bubbly, friendly, and really made our night! Iv never had such excellent service. Heather the manager was amazing and friendly, made everyone feel welcome. All servers that were working had smiles and are friendly. So huge thank you! ? definitely will come back!”

“Best food truck in Wyoming! This guys BBQ is so darned good you'll dream about it!!! Not only is it delicious and quick for those of us who only have so much time at lunch but the portions will make your belly happy twice! Had the burrito and ate it for lunch, dinner and then breakfast the next day with some eggs. If you like pork, BBQ, FOOD, you need to try this guy, you won't be disappointed. See you soon, lunch hour is @ noon :)”

Customers` Favorites

“Food was good. We got what we wanted.”

Customers` Favorites

“Great place and food”

Customers` Favorites

“We celebrated my husbands 65th birthday at Open Range Bar and Grill. We could not have chosen a better place, everything was perfect! Manny, our waiter was phenomenal, he helped to make our birthday celebration very special! The dinner was exceptional (rack of elk-see photo); in addition, the chef made the rounds to all the tables after each table finished, adding a nice touch. The ambiance of the dining room had a ton of ‘period' character (see photo). The restaurant is located in the Sheridan inn from the late 1800s. The inn is beautifully restored and well maintained. Entire staff of hotel also very friendly. We will return again next year for the Sheridan leatherwork trade show. Open range will definitely be a part of that visit!! Thanks everyone:)”

Customers` Favorites

“Omg where do I start! This place is so awesome and got some great staff! They are very friendly and they treat you like family! Some of you may know they are now serving food it's very delicious. When you are in there it is pleasant they also have made it non smoking in doors but have a smoke hut they are currently working on. But this is definitely a great place to go and have a drink or to oh ya don't forget to get some food I love love there burgers and fresh fries ,also love there wings and there home made pizzas! Omg killer work yall keep it up! Don't forget this bar also has 3 pool tables, a foosball table, darts, and even a claw machine that has some really cool stuff. Come, check it out !”

“I had my first ever SMOOTHIE last week. Interesting texture carefully concocted with the freshest, healthiest ingredients. Cute little spot tucked in an out of the way place perfect to sit in the cool and work on one of the many jigsaw puzzles offered in their Puzzle Exchange nook.Try it. You'll like it.”

Customers` Favorites

“Simply Amazing experience. Told them about my Garlic/Onion allergy and supremely accommodating. The Mango Curry was amazing, the Calamari cooked perfectly and Whatever the sauce was that came with the Garden Rolls... Don't get any on your forehead... your tongue will beat your brains out trying to get to it.10/10 we will eat here again before we leave!!Dietary restrictions: Garlic/ Onion / Dairy Allergies. Just told them. No issues!”

Customers` Favorites

“New owners are decent and friendly. The food is the best in town in my opinion. They smoke their meat for 8 hour's every day, so get it while you can, they run out pretty quick.”

“Amazing place we stopped at on our road trip. Great food that was freshly made that day and not at all heavy. Fresh and clean. Nearly everything there to order is made onsite and the same day. Will be marking this place down as a go to if we are in the area.”

“I was looking for a valentine's day gift for my husband and Donna went above and beyond to help! My husband absolutely loved his Jack Daniel's flavored cheesecake would recommend not only for amazing customer service but amazing cheesecake as well!”

Customers` Favorites

“It's definitely one of the nicest restaurants/bars in Sheridan. Nice outdoor seating area with tabletop fireplaces. Happy hour deals, good food, and a large draft beer selection.”

Customers` Favorites

“Husband enjoyed the great beer, I enjoyed the gluten free options. Thanks for taking care of us even though we showed up close to closing. We will definitely return next time through!”

Customers` Favorites

“Great pizza. Always freshly made. The people there are incredibly friendly. I showed up early to grab and order and the stopped their other orders to get mind some more quickly. Highly recommended for a take and bake meal!”

Customers` Favorites

“Yep, Karen might be the best server ever. Her "people skills" and seeming devotion to perfectly serving her guests was amazing, what a gem. The ribeyes were also excellent both nights I visited!”

Customers` Favorites

“If you've ever had a Moe's SW grill or similar, I find Qdoba to be a bit better. More combinations that are always super tasty, and just better ingredients I think. It's basically a Mexican ”

“Stopped in here the other day and bought some birthday cake cookies. They were so good!! They have a large selection of baked goods. I was told they will be opening a seating area soon. I would reccomend stopping in and getting a treat!”

“The Big Horn Y is an absolute gem. The Team is dedicated, friendly and the food is top-notch! Everything coming out of the Patio window is fantastic. The Pork Street Tacos, Seared Ahi Sandwich, Shrimp Po-Boy & the Spicy Meatloaf Sandwich are personal favorites. Also- there is an always changing assortment of homemade desserts in the cold case. A++!”

“I've really enjoyed meeting Matt and discussing coffee. I have tried several varioations and a blend and all have been very smooth. I prefer a medium roast and he will roast to your specifications. If you want good, fresh roasted coffee this is the place.”

“Always a friendly place and easy to mingle. Probably the only place In sheridan that the bar tender comes out to serve drinks rather then just being behind the bar.”

Customers` Favorites

“The best place to get a late night bite! If you’re rolling into town late or leaving the bar late this place has a great bite to offer! The food is great and the service to get it to you your food fast that late in the evening is amazing! Wish I could give more stars!!”

Customers` Favorites

“They have a decent selection of local craft beers and a great selection of food items. We tried the Beer Rocks as an appetizer, LOVED it!!! For dinner, we ordered the pizza sampler. We tried the Bacon Mac n chz, Jalapeño Popper, Greek, and the Chicken Alfredo. They were all Amazing!! For dessert, we ordered the Raspberry Brulee Cheesecake. So so so yummy!!! It was a very busy night so the wait times were long. The server was very pleasant but didn't check back often enough and we sat for a good 20 mins without drink refills. Must have been an off night. Would definitely go back!”

Customers` Favorites

“I love that every time I eat here, the food is always good. It consistently tastes the same as it always has. The service is always good. Sometimes we have to wait a bit, but we never mind cause the atmosphere is also good.”

“Stopped here on our way through town. The building set up was a little confusing. They had a deli counter (including a Chester's chicken), a pub, and a self seating area. They all serve the same food but the pub also serves alcohol. We stopped in for the BBQ which seems strange for a place called an Irish Pub. Again just adding to our confusion. Once we figured out how to order food things were good. Some items were bland while others were really good. One of the staff members seemed annoyed with us because we didn't know what was going on. So that was not great. But all of that aside it was a nice place to stop for a bite to eat.”

Customers` Favorites

“Get the House fried rice! Definitely the BEST Chinese fried rice ever! Trust me, I’ve been eating and cooking Asian food for all of my life. The fried rice is not greasy, has good amount of protein and beansprout(!), with a hint of spice, and also the char from the wok - which is hard to get when cooking at home.My family would eat it everyday if we lived here!”

“One of the coolest bars we have been to.”

“Visiting the Sidewalk Cafe is such a pleasant experience! The staff is very friendly, the music is inviting, and they have fun and unique coffee flavors without being overly sweet (IMO). Not to mention, they're super affordable. Definitely check out this hidden gem for your next caffeine boost!”

Customers` Favorites

“Come here on Wednesdays a lot and it never disappoints! Heidi is so nice and the food is delicious and timely! My wife loves the Thai tea and the curry! I always get the bubble tea and the egg rolls. never disappointed!”

Customers` Favorites

“Sapporo Sheridan transforms dining into an experience. With a menu rich in authentic Japanese flavors and live teppanyaki that entertains, it’s more than just food—it’s a performance. What truly sets Sapporo apart is the manager’s enthusiasm and remembrance of customers; makes each visit feel personal and special, far beyond a simple meal. The ambiance marries comfort with elegance, ensuring every visit is memorable. For a unique blend of culinary excellence and heartfelt hospitality, Sapporo earns a well-deserved five stars.Parking: Large shared lot with multiple entry/exit pointsKid-friendliness: Staff goes above and beyond for the kids, sings, goofs around and even cotton candy :)Wheelchair accessibility: Easy accessibility , all one level, tables accessible”

Customers` Favorites

“For the price it's good. Not the greatest Chinese buffet I've ever been to. Could definitely use some upgrades. It's Always the same Soundtrack when we go it's some kind of Disney instrumental not what you think you would hear. There's been a few times we put are jackets on while eating. The restaurants seem as cold. The staff is friendly for the most and the place is very clean. Not a whole lot of options but for the area it's great.”

Customers` Favorites

“Nice simple atmosphere. I can agree with other reviews that the price appears high, but IMO the steak is worth it, and the sides that come with it are also very good. And if you are on a road trip and need a good steak, this is the stop. I dont regret a dollar spent here.”

Customers` Favorites

“Food and selection was great!! The fries were amazing ? waitress was helpful in helping me pick out a dish but could have been a tad more attentive. Cute and laid back atmosphere. Really enjoyed this place!”

Customers` Favorites

“The young man that took out order was still in training but did a wonderful job keeping a good attitude and not stressing about the ever growing line in the lobby. The only problem I had was I ordered the wrong chicken on my burrito, but that was my bad.”

Customers` Favorites

“Dairy Queen is a Great "Go-to" spot when you have a little extra time. That's where I found myself the other day. So I bought a shake and some fries then went on to the top of a hill overlooking town and enjoyed my afternoon treat. I really like DQ's shakes and their fries are good too. Only took a couple minutes in the drive thru and I was all set. I've enjoyed DQ visits since I was a kid. I'm sure you will find a shake you'll enjoy from their many flavors you will like on a hot day too.”